November, Thanksgiving, and the Quiet Practice of Noticing Yourself
November arrives quietly. The light shifts. Mornings feel heavier, evenings come sooner, and the world seems to exhale after the busyness of fall. Trees stand bare or nearly so, and there is a collective turning inward—toward memory, reflection, and meaning.
It is also the month when gratitude becomes a word we hear everywhere.
Thanksgiving invites us to pause, gather, and give thanks. We are encouraged to notice what is good in our lives—to name blessings, comforts, and moments of joy. Gratitude lists reappear, conversations turn toward appreciation, and for many, this practice feels grounding and familiar.
But November can also carry a different emotional weight.
For some, it brings grief. For others, loneliness, family strain, financial stress, or exhaustion from a year that asked too much. And in those moments, gratitude—at least as it is commonly practiced—can feel distant or even hollow.
After years of sitting in therapy spaces with clients, I have come to believe that gratitude needs to be gentler, deeper, and more inclusive of the human experience.
Because gratitude is not only about noticing what is good around us.
It is more about noticing the goodness within us.
“This is not positive thinking. It is accurate thinking.”
When Gratitude Feels Out of Reach
“Traditional gratitude asks us to notice what we have. A deeper practice invites us to notice who we are—especially when life is complicated, tender, or uncertain.”
Traditional gratitude often focuses outward: what we have, what went well, what we can name as positive. And there is value in this. But when life is painful or uncertain, this approach can quietly turn into pressure.
Be thankful.
Look on the bright side.
At least it’s not worse.
Others have it worse.
When clients tell me they feel like they are “failing at gratitude,” it is rarely because they are ungrateful people. It is because they are human—living through seasons that are complicated, tender, or deeply hard.
This is where I offer this reframe, one that sits at the heart of my work.
Gratitude does not disappear when things fall apart.
“When life is hard, gratitude doesn’t disappear—it simply needs a different direction.”
In fact, that is when we need it the most.
And it simply needs a different direction.
Turning Gratitude Inward
What if gratitude was not only about external circumstances but about self-recognition?
What if, instead of asking, “What am I grateful for?” we also asked:
“What does this moment say about me?”
When something good happens in your life, you are there.
And when something difficult happens, you are there too.
You are the one who shows up, adapts, survives, feels, overcomes, achieves, rests, tries again, or chooses not to. Yet we so rarely acknowledge our own presence, strength, or goodness—especially when no one else sees it.
I encourage a practice that goes beyond positivity. It is not about convincing yourself that everything is fine. It is about telling the truth with kindness. It’s about telling yourself the truth about yourself.
A Daily Emotional Regulation Practice
There are many elements important in the area of emotional regulation (finding that middle spot where our ideas and feelings are expressed in the middle spot between too much and not enough): Mindfulness, Distress Tolerance, and Interpersonal Scripting. Within mindfulness practice lies the practice of Self-Affirmation, and this is where gratitude from within matters the most. It turns out that emotionally regulated people do in fact walk around with sustainably ‘good’ views of themselves, connected to frequent and regular ‘wins’ in their lives.
One simple practice I offer clients—especially during emotionally charged seasons like November—is this:
At the end of the day, pause and ask:
- What went well today? (Even on, especially on bad/hard days).
- Where did I show up today?
- What did I carry, even quietly?
- What strength did I use without realizing it?
- What does today reveal about my resilience?
The answers are often small, but they are powerful.
“I got out of bed even though I didn’t want to.”
“I said no when it would have been easier to say yes.”
“I let myself cry.”
“I rested instead of pushing.”
“I made it through a hard conversation.”
“I took a chance on something important to me.”
I offer clients a short daily meditation that has several parts to it. One part is: “What went well was when _______ happened and that reminded me that I am a ________________ person.”
This is gratitude rooted in reality.
This is self-affirmation, which balances the brain so that even when bad things are happening, we don’t lose sight of our goodness.
Thanksgiving When Life Is Messy
Thanksgiving has a way of magnifying emotion. Family dynamics surface. Empty chairs are felt more deeply. Comparisons creep in. Expectations hover.
If this Thanksgiving feels joyful, you are allowed to savor it.
And if it feels heavy, you are allowed to name that too.
Gratitude does not require pretending.
You may not be grateful for everything that has happened this year. But you can still be grateful to yourself.
Grateful that you endured.
Grateful that you learned something about yourself.
Grateful that you are still here, still becoming.
I have experienced and written about the slow return to self after loss—the way healing often happens in quiet, unremarkable moments. Not through grand transformations, but through staying, through visiting, and through ‘hearing’ your ‘healthy self,’ daily.
Thanksgiving is an opportunity to honor that staying.
A Gentle Thanksgiving Reflection
This Thanksgiving, I invite you to try a softer kind of gratitude practice—one that includes you.
Begin by taking a few slow breaths. Let your body settle where you are.
Then, without judgment, acknowledge what this season feels like for you.
Finally, complete this sentence, in writing or silently:
“This year, I am grateful that I am someone who…”
Let the answer be honest. Let it be simple.
“I am grateful that I kept going.”
“I am grateful that I am learning to be kinder to myself.”
“I am grateful that I didn’t give up.”
You do not need to earn this gratitude.
You only need to notice yourself.
Gratitude as Relationship
At its heart, gratitude is relational. And the most enduring relationship you will ever have is the one you have with yourself.
When we learn to notice our own goodness—especially when life is hard—we build trust. We stop abandoning ourselves in moments of struggle. We remember that worth is not dependent on circumstances going well.
As November deepens and Thanksgiving approaches, may your gratitude expand.
May it include the meals and the moments—but also the quiet strength it took to arrive here.
You were there for your life this year.
And that matters.
“This Thanksgiving, I invite people to consider a different question: not only ‘What am I grateful for?’ but ‘What am I grateful about myself?’ Because the relationship we build with ourselves shapes every other relationship we have.”
– Karen Goslin
- Connect with Karen Goslin
- More articles from our Executive Contributor, Karen Goslin
